IDHAR UDHAR KI BAAT 54 – EXUBERANCE OR RASHNESS OR STUPIDITY
"I haven't had sex yet. God don't let me die. I am just 22 plus," I whispered my prayers to the God. I was in a 'stay behind party' where I was taking stock of the blunders I committed. In exuberance I had decided to keep myself with three other jawans hiding under the bushes in the abandoned LTTE camp in the jungles of Sri Lanka. The first thing which went wrong was the radio communication with my two jawans hiding fifteen meters away. The batteries of their VM Mk 2A radio set had gone dead. During day we could communicate with hand signals but with the nightfall everything was left to chance. There was no worthwhile night vision device with us and we had to rely on our ears only. Sitting in the dark I was wondering that the man who wrote procedure of attack across the ditch cum bund must have never operated in the dark. Otherwise he wouldn’t have expected a breakout before first light.
I remembered that the leader of the party who was to respond in case of imminent threat was not that capable. I was not sure whether he had deployed properly around eight hundred meters away. But then I realised that my jawans with him are highly reliable so they will take up the challenge when required. The plan to be in 'stay behind party' was purely driven by my imagination or longing to kill the Tamil Tigers in case they returned to the camp. Now the thought of Tigers coming in multitude haunted me. The bushes were just the place for hiding. There was no defensibility. Only defensible thing was the placing of four claymore mines. It was thought that I will be able to hold on to the Tamil Tigers for some time with the combination of mines and small arms fire and my party would come to our help. And then I remembered of a recent case where the party which had to respond had not responded in time for some reason, resulting in the massacre of a few men. I now remembered that I had not cleaned the barrel of my Carbine yesterday before taking off for the operation. Again a mistake as it had developed the stoppage of size se mota round in the last encounter. Overall I was worried the whole night for I had planned this operation purely on keenness and haste without giving details to my seniors.
I remembered the words of Brig LP Sen in his book ‘Slender was the thread’ about some officer who died along with his soldiers “It was brought about by enthusiasm which blinded the individual concerned and led him to an act of unjustified rashness and stupidity.”
At the first light my buddy wrote something on his diary and passed it on. It read ‘9 man’. With his eyes he pointed towards half left. Apni Phati (I got scared) because nine men from one side means the Tamil Tigers are coming in multitude. When I scanned the area I only saw some deer grazing. I realised that in Tamil a deer is called a मन(Māṉ). It was a big relief as I felt that our concealment was so good that the deer also could not detect. Another fifteen minute I was thinking that I will have to instruct the company cook to use less of hing (asafoetida) as the smell became unbearable. I know my buddy also must be finding my emissions unbearable. But he didn’t complain. Perhaps that is also unspoken part of the espirit de corp. Again I realised that it was a folly of not planning the food intake of the nominated stay behind party well in advance. Such type of operations require a lot of planning. It is not just the arms and ammunition and good firing that a group transforms into a commando. Years of culture and training makes a unit and subunit capable enough.
As the time passed it became unbearable to stay there, but my resolve was not letting me give up. I was thinking that we must be there till the last light. But then God was kind, as one member of the team had severe dehydration and we had to abort the operation by noon. On my way back I was thinking that I will have to be more deliberate and keep a check on my exuberance. I was remembering that my parents will not be able to bear my loss. My sister had written that my father had developed hypertension. Any news of a soldier’s death and he stops talking till the name of the soldier is seen on the media. His hands shake even to read a normal telegram from his office.
But the very next week I was running after a group of Tamil Tigers like an idiot. Or conducting operations throwing caution to the four winds. That stupidity or exuberance of mine continued even in my RR Tenure as company commander. I was lucky nothing bad happened.
It is only when I went to command the RR Battalion that I did things with great patience and deliberations. To the extent that my young officers felt that ‘budda is coward’ till the time we got first success at no cost of life or injury. Thus, I demonstrated to them that they can still kill the terrorist. Beyond my unit command I stopped worrying about the loss of life as I slipped into the Mainu Ki attitude.
But one day I heard the screams of a mother of a young soldier killed in action. Those cries pierced my heart and I wrote a book about my experiences to serve as a lesson for the future generation to help save lives. Unfortunately, very few people are in the habit of reading these days.
Death of a soldier when the terrorists have launched an offensive action is understandable. But death of soldier when we have launched the operation smells of immaturity. Young soldiers will be impulsive and impatient. At that age and service, they are expected to be so. But if we lose lives, it clearly means that some Commanding Officer or above is on a vacation or indulging in bean counting.
Every time I hear about a soldier’s death during an operation undertaken by them, I feel it could have been prevented.
Wonderful as ever! Switch to "a full time author. "
ReplyDeleteMay not be a bad idea after all 😊
Excellent. And again telling it like it is.
ReplyDeleteAmazing as always PSG!
ReplyDeletePSG… too gud… i know d feeling… god bless our soldiers who follow us in full faith🫡🫡
ReplyDeleteVery touching!!
DeleteAnother short coming in our plg is pack meals which is primarily Puri, Pickles and Onions.......it can be smelled from miles
ReplyDeleteDear Sir , Your memoirs are so realistic and easy to perceive, reading them one gets engrossed in the scene you are narrating . Each and every sentiments, fear , emotion shared was so genuine .
DeleteI loved reading it. Hope the young leaders get to read and grasp the essence of a plethora of combat wisdom and sentiments shared by you .
👏👏👏👏👏👏🫡
Very well articulated with humility and reality ! Infantry officers can relate.
DeleteBeautifully Articulated Sir. Love to read your experiences and there is so much to learn. You rightly said, People don’t read these days. 🫡
ReplyDeleteDear PSG
ReplyDeleteHow beautifully narrated . Absolutely crystal clear , what goes in the mind and what silly aberrations we do .
Keep the quill soaked in ink
It is always a pleasure to read your columns and one can often relate indirectly to events in fauj / everyday life. Idhar Udhar ki Baat rocks .
ReplyDeleteSir,
ReplyDeleteA wonderful narration and capture of blood and sweat and the associated emotions !
Always wait for your stories.
Very well articulated …
ReplyDeleteIt was another wonderful narration that all ur readers can so well connect with.
ReplyDeletePl also share the details of ur book
HS Phagura ☝️
ReplyDeleteWonderful read 😀👌👌
ReplyDeleteSir great. Your penning down style is so realistic that it starts screening the events in back of mind.👌👏👏👏😘
ReplyDeleteBang on sir ! Our conversation of having a documented experience reservoir refers ! Regards
ReplyDeleteAnother gem in the collection
ReplyDeleteBy all yardsticks u don’t have a Mainu Ki Attitude. Wonderful as ever. And yes, the loss of a life leaves behind many scratched souls. Thanks
ReplyDeleteSo true, those of us who have been on ground had very similar experiences 🙏
ReplyDeleteAnother Gem from your rich experience in the organisation. Stay blessed.
ReplyDeleteA death of a soldier in any kind of ops is a loss to a paltan n great tragedy to near n dear ones.It is duty of the Commanding Officer to ensure that there is a minimum cas of his men.The Command is successful when the paltan is deinducted without any loss to life.Unit citations is secondary.A nice article PS.Keep it up buddy.
ReplyDeleteExcellent narration of the Trials and Tribulations of a YO and ensuing levels of Command.We have all gone through Similar experiences.
ReplyDeleteSo nicely penned dear. Absolutely relatable, candid and spot on as usual.
ReplyDeleteHatsoff to your memory or you were maintaining a diary since then ...but so realistic are the events that a soldier gets engrossed while reading your stories...nice ..please keep it up
ReplyDeleteExcellent real life like narration. Makes it a compulsive reading to the end. Kudos
ReplyDeleteExcellent as usual, great lesson and need for planning at lower level well highlighed sir.
ReplyDeleteGood writing . Brings alive the situation quite vividly !!
ReplyDeleteKeep up the writing !!
The brigadier brings military tactical and human lessons in a humourus manner, underlying tinge of actual fear and loss can be detected. The getting over it, is the definition of a soldier. Writing about what he feels about it in hindsight is a rarity. Though, many feel it, putting it in on paper so aptly, is his greatness.
ReplyDeleteAbsolutely relatable and true in its entirety. Well articulated Sir
ReplyDeleteDear sir awesome short story. Regards
ReplyDeleteMatter of fact writing of a grounded soldier.
ReplyDeleteWith your vast operational experience dear Gothra, you can really enlighten future generations of soldiers and save their lives too. Kudos and best wishes.
Good one PS
ReplyDeleteVery well written, I don’t have direct exposure to the incidents related here, however, as a family member, you miss the heart beat when those stories are recounted. I enjoy your stories and also each comment, because that’s another story in itself. Now I know why fauji’s talk so much😂😂. They have so many experience and exposures under their hats
ReplyDeletePatience is the key to successful operations. It is a fine art of trying to rein in the exuberance of young soldiers, only to release it at opportune moment. Those who master are true leaders of men.
ReplyDeleteToo good sir! Brings back similar memories!
ReplyDeleteIt's always a delight to read your columns, and they often strike a chord with experiences in the fauj and daily life. Idhar Udhar ki Baat is truly exceptional!
ReplyDeleteExcellent write up.....The heading made you curious .....the narrative kept you engrossed and actually brought out lessons learnt the hard way in difficult situations.....Death of a soldier in the unit lowers the morale of every one and the biggest welfare is training...train to live another day...Wonderful narrative which brings out the nuances in an interesting manner
ReplyDeleteIt’s always a pleasure reading your experiences sir and the message being conveyed through it .
ReplyDeleteExcellent read sir. Your writings remind me of 'The Defence of Duffer's Drift '. I strongly recommend you publish them for posterity. These basic lessons will be a good step to further reduce loss of life.
ReplyDeleteWonderful story Sir. It captures the innards of infantry battle drills and procedures along with the human emotions and reactions thereto. This is like a complete capture of event in its fullness which often gets glossed over. Do write more such stories
ReplyDeleteHaving been in similar operations, your narration is so very relatable. You have lucidly brought out situations and emotions which we brush off as routine matters. In operations we need both - the exuberance and enthusiasm of the youth as well as the wisdom and restraint of the senior. Always look forward to your stories PS.
ReplyDeleteSatish
Great experience, well written, shows all the feelings of a soldier in the face of death/ victory. There is very little different between the two in an operation. Beautifully brought out
ReplyDeleteGut wrenching and authentic!
ReplyDeleteWill make any combatant reminisce & smile. Lucid & laced with humour as ever 😊
ReplyDelete