IDHAR UDHAR KI BAAT 93- THANKS AD GUYS Brig PS Gothra (Retd)

“It’s surely enemy drones,” I muttered to myself, squinting at the dark sky on that blackout night as a sinister humming sound buzzed overhead.
And suddenly—flashback! My mind drifted to 1990. Someone standing over a sand model had confidently declared, “Revolution in Military Affairs (RMA) is round the corner.” I had waited... and waited... and honestly, I didn’t see it. Not till I hung my boots three years ago.
But tonight—there it was. The RMA. Hovering right above my head, like an uninvited UFO with possibly explosive intentions.

As a civilian (yes, a retired fauji is technically a civilian, but don’t tell my moustache that), there's not much you can do in such a moment—except pray the warhead hits a few metres away from you and not dead centre. I wondered what the Air Defence (AD) guys were doing. And just then—bam! Guilt hit me harder than a court of inquiry.

For most of my career, I had treated AD officers like Fair & Lovely cream—apply when needed, and then toss aside.
It all started in the Academy. Our general consensus? “AD guys are going to be in peace stations their whole life, cruising in air-conditioned vehicles.” Jealous? Maybe. Wrong? Possibly.

Then came the Staff College exam prep. I remember struggling with the zillion types of weapon configurations. One smart aleck comforted me: “Don’t worry. Nobody asks AD questions. Even the paper-setters are terrified. Anyway, war’s not going to escalate to the Air Force.”
Classic words before drone warfare became the norm.

My first close encounter with AD came when I commanded an RR battalion. We had two companies of AD soldiers. I was sceptical about their counter-terror (CT) skills. That lasted... a week. With minimal guidance, they turned out to be absolute rockstars.

Later, as Director in Military Intelligence, I had two AD officers posted with me—unheard of in that CT-focused infantry bastion. My seniors raised eyebrows, but I soon realised these guys were sharper than me. (Not that I told anyone.)

Even as Brig Q, while pitching for new accommodation for an AD Brigade posted at a godforsaken location, I was told by a very senior officer, “These guys will always remain…” (He never finished the sentence. Probably ran out of stereotypes.)

Then there was that infamous story of an officer who had a nervous breakdown in an RR sector. He was replaced by an AD officer—whom I was sure would buckle under pressure. Nope. The sector ran smoother than ever. That same officer made the legendary “Hotshots CD”—a staff college lifesaver for many courses after. (If you know, you know.)

Truth is—AD guys are brilliant. Maybe too brilliant. They explain things with such jargon-packed complexity, commanders either keep them at arm’s length or pretend to understand. Someone even told me, “Hawai ladai to hone wali nahin hai”—air warfare is remote possibility. Some AD folks, frustrated with this neglect, resorted to nautanki just to be seen.

And then there’s the Air Force-AD tension. A few decades ago, the Air Force was paranoid, AD might accidentally shoot their aircraft down. (Spoiler: It actually happened in Pakistan.) Hence the ultra-strict rules of engagement.

But that night, I heard the AD guns thunder. Within seconds, the drones dropped like overcooked tandoori turkeys. Applause erupted. I stood up, gave a crisp salute, and said, “Good job, AD boys. You’ve done it again.”

That night, I actually started thinking hard to list points for modernising AD in light of this drone-RMA reality. Then I stopped myself and chuckled Din’ “Anari ka sochna, soch ka satyanash.”

Note:-

1.       I wonder how many of you know the actual song ‘Anari Ka Khelna..’ of film ‘Woh Saat Din’. Some of the stalwarts must have hummed the corrupted version of the song.

2.       A follow button has been placed in the header. Please follow if the blogs bring a smile. 

 

#IndianArmy   #AirDefence    #DroneWarfare    #MilitaryHumour   #VeteranVoices    #ModernWarfare    #RMA    #Faujistory #DefenceBlog    #TandooriDrones    #JaiHind

Comments

  1. There is no doubt, thanks for saying so

    ReplyDelete
  2. Brigadier RS SethiMay 20, 2025 at 9:17 AM

    Nicely brought out. Bang on!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Excellent narration....being an AAD guy myself, I can really relate....👍🏻

    ReplyDelete
  4. Totally relatable as an AAD guy and former Director of Project Akashteer that did some magic. Lovely write up👏👏

    ReplyDelete
  5. Tandoori Turkeys 🦃. Nicely put and a breezy read. Loved it.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Excellent write up and so very true. AD boys saved our bacon!

    ReplyDelete
  7. I too had same opinion about AD guys, they had good technical knowledge but as soldier always use to have doubt. They have indeed proven there soldierly skills in OP-Sindoor inspite of old equipment L-70. Maybe there right time had not arrived than.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Absolutely right
    AD has proved its tech competence and effectiveness beyond doubt.
    Seperstion of AD from fd arty has paved the way for its perfect performance in Sindhoor.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Excellent performance of our AD has won the recent conflict for us.

    ReplyDelete
  10. An excellent ode to the AD gunners

    ReplyDelete
  11. Brother Param,
    loved the phrase 'Tandoori Turkeys'. So apt. Keep dishing more.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Very nicely written. Yes, AD urgently requires fresh acquisitions & more budget allocation.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Excellent write up , so far we were only utilising ZU twin barrels in direct role , actually AD Gunners were always highly professional, because their reaction time was of seconds only and the vision was really far beyond the horizon, only thing lacking was targets ,now they had enough opportunities and proved their capacity, otherwise they were only made to shoot on the sleeve towed behind ac. AD always had better soldiers.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Excellent write up Sir. RMA has truly arrived. There needs to be more capability building in this domain

    ReplyDelete
  15. 🫡🤓.. Salute from your ex Coy Cdr from AD. I can relate to all the above .. being from the other side as an Arm and same side having had the honour and privilege to serve with you.

    ReplyDelete
  16. An apt narration
    This skirmish was of course their reckoning. AD has proved it's existence to the new generation which saw the war coming to them. Ofcourse the AD needs modernisation and integration at all levels to thwart any aggression by the adversaries. Specially when we have a hawk eyed China looking diligently over our northern borders. India should be concerned and prepared for future 2.5 or 3 front war.
    There might be a situation like Israel where survival will require substantial investment in all spheres incl AD shield

    ReplyDelete
  17. Totally relatable. Very well written and aptly brought out. Proud to be from Air Defence.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Whatever doubts the Rest of the Army had about the efficacy and utility of AAD has been put to rest with this performance. Only hope this serves to get them the much needed upgrades.

    ReplyDelete
  19. No job is good or bad - its true measure is in its accomplishment- this is exactly what our AD fraternity has executed with finesse in the recent operations - may the Corps grow in strength & valour !!!

    ReplyDelete
  20. Mildly put, but conveys the crux of the recent exploits of our AAD! Once upon a time the Signalers and Engineers were always first into the battle. Now it's the AD. Sophisticated systems are hard to come by as a nation becomes more and more developed economically, diplomatically and militarily. I recall the tremendous amount of resistance folks who matter had, regarding inducting the Akash weapon systems, little realising that such sophisticated system of systems will not be parted with easily by the big boys (US, Russia etc). They did everything possible to thwart the effort. It is the perseverance of the DRDO and the the then Project Director that we see the results today. Sky is the Anvil and AD the Hammer. Well Done Boys!

    ReplyDelete
  21. Changing nature of warfare is ore related to developments in Science &Technology. Sometimes, One - upmanship, Dominance & turf wars refuse to accept the obvious. Nicely put across, as usual.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Correction pl. For "ore" read "more", above.

      Delete
  22. The first time I came across the words, Turkey shoot, was when I read about the Battle of the Philippines Sea in WW2: it was about an aerial battle where hundreds of Japanese fighter aircraft were shot down by US forces.

    Reading the article above and to the 'Tandoori Turkeys', it was ironical and amusing to note that the Indian AD gunners too had a Turkey shoot recently, only with the real Turkish drones!

    ReplyDelete
  23. No doubt AAD guys made the whole country proud. since they hv proved their mettle they now need to be equipped with best of the wpns.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

IDHAR UDHAR KI BAAT 80 (The Maha Kumbh and CNP) Brig PS Gothra (Retd)

IDHAR UDHAR KI BAAT 78- CHITHI - Brig PS Gothra (Retd)

IDHAR UDHAR KI BAAT 17- (POSITION OF STRENGTH) Brig PS Gothra (Retd)